There’s no telling how we got here, but true crime podcasts somehow manage to persevere and stay relevant—even as the most overdone podcast genre in existence.

Yes, it’s a dramatic statement, but that doesn’t make it any less true.

The point is, many true crime podcasters have tried to shake things up and carve out new sub-genres. But this one might just take the cake:

Sex, deep friendships, and religion. All set against the backdrop of the desert.

It might sound idyllic at first, but true crime fans know better. Once the handsome outsider blows into town, everything is bound to unravel.