

Phoebe Judge has spent more than a decade telling stories about people “who’ve done wrong, been wronged, or gotten caught somewhere in the middle.” Before that, she was a public radio reporter on the Mississippi Gulf Coast, covering the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina and the BP oil spill for Mississippi Public Broadcasting and NPR, and then a producer on The Story with Dick Gordon at WUNC in North Carolina.
When The Story was cancelled in 2013, Judge, Lauren Spohrer, and Eric Mennel started Criminal, recording the early episodes in closets. The first one came out in January 2014, months before true crime became a universal pastime. Criminal joined PRX’s Radiotopia network, and in 2021 Vox Media bought Criminal Productions, the studio behind Criminal, This Is Love, and Phoebe Reads a Mystery.
The New York Times named Criminal one of the best podcasts of 2023.
This month she takes the stage with Don’t Worry with Phoebe Judge, a 13-city tour that turns Criminal’s premise on herself. She grew up in an eccentric, unpredictable family in Chicago and started discovering family secrets at eight. The show is about how those secrets shaped her life, her journalism, and eventually Criminal itself. It opens November 17 at The Vic in Chicago and closes December 16 in Seattle.
We were lucky to connect with Phoebe ahead of the tour to talk about finally telling her own story, how her family shaped Criminal, and where true crime goes from here.
SO: You’ve spent twelve years telling other people’s stories and keeping yourself mostly out of them. Don’t Worry flips that. Why tell your own now, and was there a moment you knew you were ready?
PJ: I met a woman recently who asked how I’m able to talk to people about terrible moments in their lives, and the woman said I must be a very compassionate person. It was a perfectly kind conversation, but the idea that someone needs compassion to do my job really stuck with me. I kept thinking that I’m actually not a very compassionate person. I don’t think compassion enters into the equation for me. I like what I do because I like people. I grew up with imperfect people and I’m imperfect. I thought it would be interesting and difficult to put myself out there in a new way.
SO: You started discovering, and keeping, family secrets at eight. How much of the way you approach Criminal, from what you ask to what you leave out, traces back to that kid?
PJ: I have always listened more than I talk.
SO: Criminal is known for its restraint. It gives people room, doesn’t speculate, and rarely tells listeners how to feel. Did you learn that at home before you learned it in a newsroom?
PJ: That’s interesting. I do think I grew up in a family that prioritized curiosity over absolutely everything, for better or worse. You wouldn’t get far in my family if you went around telling people what to do or how to feel.
SO: When you report someone else’s story, you can stand behind the reporting. Onstage, telling your own, you can’t. What was hardest about writing this show, and did anyone in your family get a say in what made it in?
PJ: Lauren Spohrer and I wrote the show over many months. We mostly wrote things down, she’d ask me questions, we’d write down the answers, and then the next day delete all of that and try again. It was important to us to remember that everyone has a mother, everyone has family crises, and secrets. What I’m hoping to share is how proud I am to be a member of my family. You’ll hear from them in the show.
SO: You’ve called Don’t Worry “a show about not giving up on people.” As the True Crime genre grew more and more diluted, I found that it was easy to flatten the victims and the accused in order to get to a plot point.
How has Criminal avoided that, and where do you think the genre still gets it wrong?
PJ: I don’t listen to or watch other crime shows. I don’t even really feel that we make a crime show. In an early draft of Don’t Worry, I made a joke about not even liking crime. But the truth is that I like people and I like to have frank conversations with anyone who is willing to be frank.
SO: Chicago is your hometown opener. Are there friends and family in the front row? Is anyone in that audience hearing these stories for the first time, and have you warned them?
PJ: Lots of family and good friends will be there, and yes I’ve warned them.
SO: You’ve interviewed hundreds of people about the worst moments of their lives. Now you’re the one handing over the hard parts.
Has being on this side of it changed how you’ll interview people when you’re back in the Criminal chair?
PJ: I think I’ll be saying thank you a lot more. It’s not easy to tell these stories.
SO: Criminal’s first episode came out in January 2014 and later that year a true crime boom nearly swallowed all of podcasting and left its mark on the zeitgeist. What do you remember about making a podcast before anyone was sure what sort of impact a podcast could have?
PJ: In some ways nothing has changed for us at Criminal. We have always kept our heads down and worked. We’ve always tried to be respectful to our guests, respectful to the listener, and to make something we’d like to listen to on a walk. We still pursue the stories that we can’t stop talking about over dinner with friends. We live in North Carolina, far away from the so-called industry, and I think the show is the better for it.
SO: Every podcast is being nudged toward video right now, and so much of Criminal is your voice and the quiet around it. Does narrative audio get squeezed out, or does it become more valuable as everything else turns into a talking-head clip?
PJ: All I can say about this is that I’ve learned to put makeup on for the first time in my life.
SO: This isn’t your first live tour. I’m curious whether live shows now have a different energy or texture to them since video has taken strides.
PJ: Any time you have a group of people together in a room there is a very specific kind of energy. It feels like some of the most human stuff we can do. Even if I’m watching people in the front row fall asleep.
SO: Phoebe Reads a Mystery started early in the pandemic as one chapter of a novel a day. You’re notably a fan of a few rigid habits so I’m curious if this foray was you reaching for a bearing when the world was upside down?
PJ: Thank you for noticing. Absolutely yes. It added structure to my days, and allowed me to read a lot of books I’ve always wanted to read.
SO: This Is Love sits right next to a show about crime. Time wrote that listening to it “can feel like a contact high.”
You’ve got love on one hand and crime on the other. How do you balance that or context switch without losing your bearings.
PJ: They feel like the same show. The process of making them is exactly the same. If only listeners were as drawn to the love show as they are to the crime show.
SO: Tell me about what you do that has nothing to do with crime, or podcasts? (What are your hobbies, or how do you clear your head after a hard story?)
PJ: I’ve always got projects going in the background. Lauren Spohrer and I are working on a series of children’s books. I’m taking flying lessons. I get outside every day with my dog, Eight. I love to water my grass.
SO: Beyond the tour, what else do you have coming up that you want to share?
PJ: Lauren Spohrer and I are about to debut a new chat show. It’s our first brand new show in a long time and I can’t wait.
SO: What are some podcasts you’re listening to these days?
PJ: When I’m not working, it’s just Blossom Dearie in my headphones.
Phoebe Judge hosts Criminal, This Is Love, and Phoebe Reads a Mystery. All three live at thisiscriminal.com.
Tickets and tour dates for Don’t Worry with Phoebe Judge are at thisiscriminal.com/live. The tour runs November 17 to December 16, 2026.
Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network, with new episodes on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
📢 Interested in sponsoring Podcast Delivery?
Book your ads today

